Fact: Removing makeup is oodles less fun than applying it, especially when it involves rubbing your eyelids raw and shedding a few lashes in the process. Nevertheless, everything that goes on must come off, so we consulted the pros who know a thing or two about the eyes and the delicate skin around them to find out what truly works best for taking off the most budge-proof of mascaras.

Surprisingly, micellar water was at the top of the list. This is probably due to the fact that the French-loved cleansers contain no alcohol, and are comprised of only dirt-loving micelle molecules that attach to makeup and debris to break it down, according to New York City-based dermatologist Debra Jaliman, MD. 

Along with those, there are also water- and oil-based gentle eye makeup removers to choose from that are highly recommended for those with sensitive eyes and sensitive skin. Read on for the full list of ophthalmologists’ and dermatologists’ tried-and-true picks that work for all skin types. That said, here are the best eye makeup removers that will demolish even waterproof makeup without taking out your eyes as collateral.