There’s something about shopping at Sephora that makes us feel like kids at a candy store. Perhaps it’s the fact that the famed beauty shop is lined with luxury beauty brands like Benefit Cosmetics, Drybar, and Stila Cosmetics. Or maybe it’s the fact that it also has exciting new brands — like the up-and-coming cosmetics line Saie — to explore. Either way, seeing those Sephora Rewards points stack up is oddly satisfying, and we could easily spend hours playing with all of the cool beauty products within Sephora’s black-and-white walls.

What’s even better is that Sephora also sells quite a few products that have earned Allure Best of Beauty Awards and Readers’ Choice Awards over the years. In fact, our seal of approval is scattered across Sephora’s website to showcase every single one of our favorite winners sold online. You can browse it fully knowing that if there’s a product you’re questioning, it’s already been tested and approved by our team for you to enjoy.

Instead of waiting for Sephora’s website to be updated with the recipients of this year’s seals, we took matters into our own hands and gathered up 26 products that have earned awards — and, best of all, every one of these is shoppable at Sephora right now.